Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
My personal opinion is that is very little difference in the quality of most of the songs in this competition. As I said earlier in the game, I believe that they are all very high quality and worthy of being in the game. I attempted to rate them with regard to music, lyrics, vocals, harmony, melody, and arrangement as I normally do in these games, however, I really was unable to do it. I think Already Gone is a great song, and the only time I personally use songwriting credits against a song is when I believe all of the other criteria I listed is equal. So, since one of these awesome songs has to go and one of them wasn’t written by any of the band members …
I cast my vote for Already Gone.
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: Results of Round 5
The next song to be eliminated in Eagles All-Star Song Survivor is Already Gone. “Already Gone”, the tribe was talking just the other day and, let me tell ya, we’ve got some news for you. You won’t be singing the victory song because we have put you on a shelf. You can stop and wonder why, but we just felt like we had to set things right. Now, pretend you’re already gone and leave the island immediately.
Votes
Already Gone – 8
Heartache Tonight – 6
Vote Breakdown
Already Gone – groupie2686
Already Gone – New Kid In Town
Already Gone – Brooke
Already Gone – Glennsallnighter
Already Gone – CAinOH
Already Gone – thelastresort
Already Gone – sodascouts
Already Gone – Ive always been a dreamer
Heartache Tonight – WalshFan88
Heartache Tonight – shunlvswx
Heartache Tonight – scottside
Heartache Tonight – My My
Heartache Tonight – Delilah
Heartache Tonight – BBKron
Songs Eliminated:
Seven Bridges Road 9/06
Waiting in the Weeds 9/08
One of These Nights 9/10
Doolin-Dalton/Desperado Reprise 9/12
Already Gone 9/14
Songs Remaining:
Take It Easy
Heartache Tonight
New Kid in Town
Voting for Round 6 begins now.
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
I'm voting for Heartache Tonight.
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
We're really getting down to it now. Whew. I don't know what I'm going to vote for.
Heartache Tonight has such a fierce ebullience.
New Kid in Town has such a poignant beauty.
And Take It Easy.... there's just something about Take It Easy. Whenever I hear it, my spirits immediately lift. And it's the one that started it all.
I just don't know!
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
I hear ya, Soda! This is hard! It's too hard!
I need to think about it...
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
Now it’s back to saving the rocker that’s left.
I vote for “New Kid In Town”.
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
Oh My Gosh this is so hard ! I vote for "Heartache Tonight". I think it is the weakest of the three remaining songs.
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
I'm voting for Heartache Tonight...again
Re: Eagles Song Survivor: All-Star Songs
This is so hard! I guess I'll have to vote for Heartache Tonight. I truly love this song and it was so rare that Glenn had a chance to really rock, but trying to be objective, it is the weakest of the three.