Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
I appreciate your explanation about NYM, Deliah, however, I just see it differently. It was obviously included on the CD for a reason, but I can't figure out what the reason was - just like I can't figure out why other songs were excluded. And it's funny how differently we feel about it because I am not at all enamored with this particular version. Even though I really do like the song a lot, there's just no way it deserves to finish in the Top 10 in this game, IMHO. So, I'll keep persisting and, hopefully, those who agree with me will join me.
Take It Easy: +1
New York Minute: -2
================
Get over it - 10
Tequila Sunrise - 16
Hotel California - 24
I Can't Tell You Why - 9
New York Minute - 17
Take It Easy - 24
Life In The Fast Lane - 15
Desperado - 16
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
New York Minute: +1
Get Over It: -2
================
Get over it - 8
Tequila Sunrise - 16
Hotel California - 24
I Can't Tell You Why - 9
New York Minute - 18
Take It Easy - 24
Life In The Fast Lane - 15
Desperado - 16
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
Get Over It: +1
I Can't Tell You Why: -2
Get over it - 9
Tequila Sunrise - 16
Hotel California - 24
I Can't Tell You Why - 7
New York Minute - 18
Take It Easy - 24
Life In The Fast Lane - 15
Desperado - 16
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
New York Minute +1
Get over it -2
Get over it 7
Tequila sunrise 16
Hotel California 24
I can't tell you why 7
New York Minute 19
Take it easy 24
Life in the fast lane 15
Desperado 16
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
New York Minute +1
Hotel California -2
Get over it 7
Tequila sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I can't tell you why 7
New York Minute 20
Take it easy 24
Life in the fast lane 15
Desperado 16
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
Desperado +1
New York Minute -2
Get over it 7
Tequila sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I can't tell you why 7
New York Minute 18
Take it easy 24
Life in the fast lane 15
Desperado 17
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
New York Minute +1
Get Over It -2
Get over it 5
Tequila sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I can't tell you why 7
New York Minute 19
Take it easy 24
Life in the fast lane 15
Desperado 17
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
Get Over It: +1
I Can't Tell You Why: -2
Get over it 6
Tequila sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I can't tell you why 5
New York Minute 19
Take it easy 24
Life in the fast lane 15
Desperado 17
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
New York Minute +1
Get Over It -2
Get Over It 4
Tequila Sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I Can't Tell You Why 5
New York Minute 20
Take It Easy 24
Life In The Fast Lane 15
Desperado 17
Re: Hell Freezes Over CD Elimination Game
Get Over It +1
New York Minute -2
Get Over It 5
Tequila Sunrise 16
Hotel California 22
I Can't Tell You Why 5
New York Minute 18
Take It Easy 24
Life In The Fast Lane 15
Desperado 17
I'm with Dreamer and Soda here. NYM is nothing special honestly IMO, especially on this version with the Eagles. One of the things that's always bothered me about HFO is how much Henley solo material is on it. It seemed like the Henley show for a fair portion with a few Eagles songs. If Henley was going to do a solo song, I'd rather hear TBOS, honestly. It fits the Eagles better too, IMO. Get Over It, however, is a great Eagles song start to finish and a true rocker. It's my favorite of the band's new music at the time and I cannot fathom it beating out GOI, honestly. I would definitely like to see it stick around a bit longer.