Search:

Yes, I did. That was more like it.

After the reunion the band took a long time to return this song to their setlist .Also, when I saw them do it, they only did the first verse & midsection, not the whole song. I was frankly...

It was nice to see that. It hasn't changed my mind about the 'official' version..

Get Over It

I care about it but the other people who expressed concern about it stated that they liked the song more than they were concerned about the fraudulence of it. So it's just you & me, it seems as well...

This. And the cynicism, the obsession with alleged 'perfectionism' apparently overriding any concern for legitimacy. As I said if Glenn went along with it it's a bad reflection on him too.

And it...

I understand what happened with it, and it wasn't right, and it turned me off the song for good.

I vote for Seven Bridges Road.

We're not just talking about overdubbing. We're talking about scrapping one of the so-called 'live' parts & replacing it with a studio part. Not only is it a studio part but it is sung by somebody...

Are you really sure that LTBS is an attack on Jesus Christ, Soda? Do you not think this interpretation may be a bit too specific?

I do agree about the probable reason for it, and let's be honest here. That's on Glenn & his mood as much as it is on the others. It would have been better not to include the song at all. But as we...

You miss the point.

The version they chose to release on their official live album is fraudulent. It is not 'live'. If they were so good the overdubs should not have been necessary. If you...

Seven Bridges Road

I don't wish to flog a dead horse, but those carefully placed audiences reactions in 7BR - are they dubbed too? I am thinking about the one after 'time sweetened honey' & I think there are a couple...

I will use your quote to explain why I am voting for Seven Bridges Road.

While I knew the live album was fake & overdubbed, for some reason I thought that 7BR was about the only track which did...

Seven Bridges Road

It used to be widely disliked; that's the point.

As long as F1 exists, then ODAAT is an Eagles song. I saw them do it. I am one of the few people on this board who did, I believe. (Where did all the people who wanted LBG gone go? I have now wasted...

As has been explained several times, One Day At A Time was performed by the Eagles before it appeared on a Joe Walsh album. It is more of a legitimate Eagles song than Life's Been Good or All Night...

Not to my knowledge.

OK... this time I will vote for Life's Been Good.

:brickwall::roll::oops:

I am now actually glad the vote didn't count, as I made such a hash of it & feel I had done the wrong thing anyway.

In this round I hereby vote for Love Will Keep Us...

Oh, OK, Dreamer! Sorry! In the past when I have bolded a song title, I always assumed you understood that was my vote. However I can see where you may have been thrown by my next comment. I...

I know all that... it's just that a few people voted for it in the previous round & I thought it would be best to help them out. I know how much you love it but nowadays I can take it or leave it. I...

I am happy to join a coalition to vote off Life's Been Good, although it isn't actually my next choice to go. It has not aged well.

Sorry Soda, but I cannot stand PCHFC, and I'd rather leave it at that than create any bad feeling.