I think it was Louisville too where TITTL got such a huge rousing ovation. From my experiences, this is still usually one of the best received songs in the setlist at shows. However, there have been a couple of occasions where I've seen the crowd just erupt and go wild over it.
Now - Do I prefer Randy's version? Yes. And the main reason is because of the way the high notes build in intensity, especially at the end of the song. There is no way that Glenn can hit those notes, but I've always said I wished that Timothy would sing them now. However, Tim has said that he didn't want to do it out of respect for Randy and I can certainly appreciate that. As much as I would love to hear it as a fan, I guess they think it might come across as 'in your face' under the circumstances ... like 'Okay Randy - you don't think you can hit those notes - well, let me show you how it's done'. So, I'll take what I can get. I'll take the song without the high notes rather than not at all any day!
"People don't run out of dreams: People just run out of time ..."
Glenn Frey 11/06/1948 - 01/18/2016
I also prefer an electric version or an orchestral version over plain acoustic. A dramatic song like TITTL benefits from arrangements that give an intense musical climax, be it with those high vocals or with dramatic instrumentation when such vocals are absent. The acoustic with its mellow strumming just never achieves that level of intensity (although it certainly is better than nothing and I still enjoy it immensely).
TITTL was in the past kind of Randy's signature song, but now that he's been out of the Eagles for over 30 years, not a lot of people even remember Randy or know that as Randy's song. I think Glenn's version is good, but it's different, as it should be. I can understand Timothy not wanting to do it. I guess Glenn thought the song was good enough to keep in the setlist & put his own spin on it....When I copied that part of the interview, I was merely pointing out that Fleder had some nice things to say about Randy....but somehow this has turned into being about Glenn....Whatever??
As for Felder, I know he is doing a music cruise, with some other groups & his daughter. I think. I also read somewhere he is doing the Jeff Probst show?? Not sure when that is.
"People don't run out of dreams: People just run out of time ..."
Glenn Frey 11/06/1948 - 01/18/2016
1. I think it is far too simplistic to say that 'not a lot of people even remember Randy or know it as Randy's song'. If they have the OOTN album they will know. People who have been fans since the 70s will know.
2. Felder says nice things about Randy, Bernie, Henley, Joe & Tim. All of them. He does NOT say nice things about Glenn. Ever.
I can only assume that the version of TITTL I have just seen is the acoustic version because Glenn plays acoustic guitar. I don't know the 'electric' version at all.