Eagles Song Survivor: One of These Nights

[EagleLady]

Um Lyin Eyes actually won a grammy, After The Thrill is Gone did not. Nuff said

[The_Girl_Of_Summer]

I Cast My Vote for Lyin' Eyes

[Brooke]

Just made it in here in time to vote! It boggles my mind that TMH could possibly be in the finals, but what can we do?

It looks like ATTIG will go this time (what a shame), so I'm voting strategically, too.

I cast my vote for Take It To The Limit. Love it, but not as much as OOTN, LE, or even ATTIG.

[TimothyBFan]

First---EV, glad to see you back!!!

IMHO, there is no freakin' way LE or ATTIG is inferior to TMH!! What the heck?

As much as it pains me, of the remaining songs, this is my least favorites so I must vote for it...

I painfully vote for After The Thrill Is Gone.

[Freypower]

But, but...it won the GRAMMY!! That means it's the best!

Honestly, I don't think anyone claimed that Lyin' Eyes is a better song because it won a Grammy (although I note EL's last post). The Grammy it won, need I say, was for Best Pop Vocal Performance by Duo or Group. It deserved that. It not only deserved it because it has awesome harmonies but because - guess what - the lead vocal is absolutely compelling. It has beautiful guitar work and a chugging rhythm section and it tells a fascinating story. It is one of the band's greatest ever songs.

I had to do that. I wish I could have been a bit more convincing.

[Prettymaid]

Welcome back EV! Hope you're able to pop in more often!

ATTIG is going tonight and needs no more help from me, so

I cast my vote for One Of These Nights

[sodascouts]

The fifth song to be voted off of One of these Nights Survivor is After the Thrill Is Gone. "After the Thrill Is Gone," it's a good thing you don't care about winning because the tribe has spoken, and it's time for you to leave the island. The rest of the songs may return to camp.

Votes
After the Thrill Is Gone - 13
Lyin' Eyes - 6
Take It to the Limit - 3
One of These Nights - 2


Vote Breakdown
After the Thrill Is Gone - EagleLady
After the Thrill Is Gone - Freypower
After the Thrill Is Gone - UK TimFan
After the Thrill Is Gone - Eve
After the Thrill Is Gone - AzEaglesFan
After the Thrill Is Gone - WildThyme
After the Thrill Is Gone - Koala
After the Thrill Is Gone - luvthelighthouse
After the Thrill Is Gone - GlennLover
After the Thrill Is Gone - sodascouts
After the Thrill Is Gone - Troubadour
After the Thrill Is Gone - pueblo47
After the Thrill Is Gone - TimothyBFan
Lyin' Eyes - Shadowland07
Lyin' Eyes - tequila girl
Lyin' Eyes - bernie's bender
Lyin' Eyes - eaglesvet
Lyin' Eyes - whitcap
Lyin' Eyes - The Girl of Summer
Take It to the Limit - Peekaboo
Take It to the Limit - Glennsallnighter
Take It to the Limit - Brooke
One of These Nights - Ive always been a dreamer
One of These Nights - Prettymaid


Songs eliminated:
Visions 6/12
I Wish You Peace 6/14
Journey of the Sorcerer 6/16
Hollywood Waltz 6/18
After the Thrill Is Gone 6/20


Songs remaining:
One of These Nights
Too Many Hands
Lyin' Eyes
Take It to the Limit




Voting for Round 6 begins after the following immunity question is answered:

Which of the songs was a number one single on Billboard?

Remember to include both your answer and the song you want immune in order for it to be counted.

[whitcap]

One of these nights
take it to the limit immune

[Eve]

One of these nights


Take it to the Limit immune

[Freypower]

One Of These Nights

Lyin' Eyes immune