American Idol 2011

[Brooke]

I'm soooooooooooooooo glad he's gone.

[sodascouts]

OH MY GOSH

http://www.tvsquad.com/2011/05/06/la...n-idol-season/

[Prettymaid]

Well I'll be...I guess I'll be watching the finale.

[Maleah]

Hmmm.....veeeeeery interesting! That's exciting! So if they continue the trend that they've had over the past few years, the contestants sing with a pro. So does that mean we get Haley/Stevie? Because if we do, I bet that will be amazing!

[Brooke]

Wow! Great news!

[sodascouts]

Just watched these on MJ's Big Blog. My thoughts:

James ("Don't Stop Believin'") - this song was made for James. He looked great too. Terrific!

Haley ("Earth Song") - The song was kind of boring but her voice was good and I liked how she got into it. I think it was a mistake to backtalk the judges, though. Makes her look kind of immature. Oh well, maybe she'll get the pity vote because Randy's "Everybody was good except Haley" bit sure made me wanna vote for her (too late now though). I mean yeah, they praised her later, but still.

Scotty ("Where Were You When the World Stopped Turning") - He sounds like such a pro. It's so hard to believe he's so young. He put a lot of emotion into the song. His best performance of the show, I think.

Lauren ("Anyway") - This song didn't really do it for me but, as with Haley, it was a good vocal. She definitely seems more confident - good for her!

Haley ("I Who Have Nothing") - Excellent vocal once again. Haley continues to impress me. Side note: If her skirts get any shorter we'll see the lace of her panties!

Scotty ("Young Blood") - Yikes, no. Is it Scotty's fault I'm cringing because of his awkward moves or is it just that the song is really lame? Probably both. Either way, I wasn't feelin' it. BTW that bit with GaGa was really weird.

Lauren ("Trouble") - Love her being so sassy! Work it! She seemed to get as little thrown with the tempo changes, especially when she was running around, but it was hardly noticeable.

James ("Love Potion #9") - He blew the doors off that song! Excellent! BTW I think GaGa is into James. lol

Who's Going Home: I liked them all, but I think either Scotty or Lauren should go home. I'm afraid it'll be Haley, though, because she seems to be the only one the judges criticize.

PS Lady GaGa freaks me out. I like "Bad Romance" but she's too much flash and not enough substance. JMHO.

[Brooke]

I thought James rocked the house! He was fabulous on both songs! I actually even voted! Twice!

I wasn't that impressed with any of the others last night.

And Gaga.........yikes! She's scary! I know she can sing, but.......And I thought she was a little much with the younger ones, Lauren and Scotty. Really!

I think Lauren or Scotty should go home. I just think they are too young.

And does anybody else think Steven Tyler is bored to death? He pretty much just sits there and says the same things to everyone.

[WalshFan88]

James needs to win this for sure.... Has that great rock voice!

I agree with Brooke that Steven Tyler does look bored though.

[WalshFan88]

WTH! James got voted off tonight. I'm definitely done watching the show... He is the best singer on that show... 70s Rock N' Roll voice, everything.

[Stars]

What a BIG disappointment to have James voted off tonight! He was definitely my favorite to win, and I even voted for him several times last night. I have to say, I am at the point now where I don't even care who wins. This is so upsetting.