I do the same thing, only with vinyl. I spilled nail polish remover on Don's Building the Perfect Beast album a few months ago (I had gotten it out before I went to his concert at Oklahoma, which ironically was why I was painting my nails in the first place, lol). Of course it's completely ruined, and yet I haven't thrown it away! Perhaps it's because it saddens me to see Don's album placed amongst coffee grinds, used wrappers, and dirty Kleenax, despite the fact that it's already ruined. I know the solution - I need to get to a used record store and buy a new one!