Okay - while I love both of these finalists for totally different reasons, for me, Already Gone has the edge even though it wasn't written by the band. First of all, I have a natural bias towards uptempo songs, which probably is one reason why I prefer Good Day in Hell so much more than Ol' 55. IMO, Already Gone stands alone on this album musically and lyrically. I also love the theme and vibe of this song. So, in case you're wondering, it's ...

Already Gone for the win!!!