If you want to play the scoring game, you need to assign them points.
And I liked both the "natural" versions of SBR, but I prefer the Seattle 1976 one.
If you want to play the scoring game, you need to assign them points.
And I liked both the "natural" versions of SBR, but I prefer the Seattle 1976 one.
Darn! But, congrats to SBR! Beautiful song! It had always been one of my favorites until I heard about all the overdubbing!
I've always loved Get Over It too, though, and still believe that it should have won.
Anyway, as far as those two live recordings posted, I like the first one best which includes Glenn's harmonica! Absolutely gorgeous! And seeing the band live helps!
Here's my list:
Get Over It-12 points
Learn to be Still-11 points
Hole in the World-10
The Girl From Yesterday-9
Seven Bridges Road-8
Love Will Keep Us Alive-7
One Day At a Time-6
Life's Been Good-5
All Night Long-4
Please Come Home For Christmas-3
Get You in the Mood-2
Funky New Year-1 (actually it should be 0 points! lol)
"They will never forget you 'till somebody new comes along"
1948-2016 Gone but not forgotten
1. Get Over It - 12 points
2. Hole In The World - 11 points
3. Please Come Home For Christmas - 10 points
4. Seven Bridges Road - 9 points
5. Love Will Keep Us Alive - 8 points
6. Funky New Year - 7 points
7. Learn To Be Still - 6 points
8. Life's Been Good - 5 points
9. All Night Long - 4 points
10. One Day At A Time - 3 points
11. Get You In The Mood - 2 points
12. The Girl From Yesterday - 1 point
Brothers for life. RIP Glenn
I'm not sure I believe in fate, but I know that crossing paths with Glenn Lewis Frey in 1970 changed my life forever, and it eventually had an impact on the lives of millions of other people all over the planet. It will be very strange going forward in a world without him in it. But, I will be grateful, every day, that he was in my life. Rest in peace, my brother. You did what you set out to do, and then some." -Don Henley
Congrats to Seven Bridges Road! Regardless of the unfortunate editing of the song, it has been a constant and consistent part of the band’s setlist for many years, for good reason.
Thanks for the link, cosec! At first the crowd noise sounded suspiciously like the Live version. It is a good version although I don’t hear much bass.
Right or wrong, what’s done is done
It’s only moments that you borrow...
1. Life’s Been Good -12
2. One Day at a Time - 11
3. Seven Bridges Road - 10
4. All Night Long - 9
5. Get You in the Mood - 8
6. Learn to Be Still - 7
7. Please Come Home for Christmas - 6
8. Get Over It - 5
9. Hole in the World - 4
10. Girl From Yesterday - 3
11. Love Will Keep Us Alive - 2
12. Funky New Year - 1
IMHO, Joe’s songs shine the most in this list.
Interesting that the top two finishers peaked at #21 (SBR) and #31 (GOI) on the Billboard charts while bottom 3 finisher PCHFC outranked them both by peaking at #18.
Right or wrong, what’s done is done
It’s only moments that you borrow...
After the reunion the band took a long time to return this song to their setlist .Also, when I saw them do it, they only did the first verse & midsection, not the whole song. I was frankly underwhelmed by it. Something else people have been neglecting to mention is the fact that they didn't write it. And even if I hadn't found out about the fraud, I was bored with it. It's a slice of Americana I guess which doesn't really appeal to me any more.
1 .Get Over It-12
2. The Girl From Yesterday - 11
3. Learn To Be Still - 10
4. Get You In The Mood - 9
5. Hole In The World - 8
6. Life's Been Good - 7
7. All Night Long - 6
8. Seven Bridges Road - 5
9. Funky New Year - 4
10. One Day At A Time - 3
11. Love Will Keep Us Alive - 2
12. Please Come Home For Christmas - 1
Hole In The World - 12
Seven Bridges Road - 11
Get You In The Mood - 10
Get Over It - 9
Life's Been Good - 8
All Night Long - 7
One Day At A Time - 6
Love Will Keep Us Alive - 5
Learn To Be Still - 4
Funky New Year - 3
The Girl From Yesterday - 2
Please Come Home For Christmas - 1
(But this is just for tonight. Tomorrow might be a different list.)
Last edited by CAinOH; 07-06-2018 at 09:31 PM.
Here's my list. LBG was always the best song on the list of songs we had. I just prefer it to everything else.
Life's Been Good - 12
Get Over It - 11
Seven Bridges Road - 10
All Night Long - 9
One Day At A Time - 8
Love Will Keep Us Alive - 7
Please Come Home For Christmas - 6
Funky New Year - 5
The Girl From Yesterday - 4
Hole In The World - 3
Get You In The Mood - 2
Learn To Be Still - 1
For me LBG was the strongest song, LTBS was the weakest song.
I did a lot of coalition voting to save what I thought was the best song - LBG. It didn't matter to me that it wasn't originally an Eagles song. I never cared for Joe's solo version or to hear him do it in his solo show. It was always a band song to me, that came alive when played with a big band with backup vocals and dueling guitars. It really shined in that atmosphere. As a record I think BSF is weak, but that's for another thread another day. I love LBG as a Eagles song.