Eagles Song Survivor: The Long Run

HOLD UP.

I miscounted. I forgot to count my own vote. Turns out the Sad Cafe should have gone.

So, now we have a problem. Restart the round or just keep going? What do you guys think? We have to decide soon... what a mess!!!

OK, I'm gonna put a freeze on the game until tomorrow night at 8:00 pm. Let's hear your thoughts.

Please vote:
1) Eliminate Sad Cafe, reinstate Those Shoes, and restart the round completely including a new immunity question.
2) Eliminate Sad Cafe, reinstate Those Shoes, restart the round... but carry over the immunity question result.
3) Resume the game as it is.

Whatever we do now will set a precedent to be followed for future Survivor games if this should ever happen again. Hopefully, of course, that will never be the case!

I vote #2!

I second the motion for #2.

Oh Soda. :hug:

I would say, option 2, as 'The sad cafe' got more votes and the immunity question was won fairly. However... it could be that the person who won the immunity question might want to save the re-instated song, in this case 'Those shoes'. So I think it would be fair to offer the option of changing the immunity to the re-instated song.

WOW--did I ever miss out on all the drama!!

I have to agree, I think #2 is the only fair option at this point but what UKTim said also....give her the option to change the immuned song.


BTW....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Troubadour

As for King of Hollywood... I think the presentation of the song mirrors the situation that's being described in the lyrics. Yes, the subject matter is seedy, but it's all packaged up in a sleek, heady, shiny exterior, much like the circumstances that the girls (wannabe actresses) in the song encounter. Everything is appealing. Los Angeles must seem like a pretty cool place when you roll up there, seeking fame and fortune and adventure. All these offers from wealthy, powerful people are exciting and tempting, and you get taken in by the promises and the expensive gifts. But lurking beneath the surface is greed and exploitation. The song is dangerous, but it's delivered in a sexy, atmospheric way. I think it absolutely works and does a great job of capturing the dichotomy between the shiny surface and the dark underbelly of Hollywood for those young women seeking stardom.

---

What she said!!!!!

Well - if this were a professional sport, and there was a mistake, the game would resume as it is. However, since it's not I would also vote for #2 with the same caveat that UK TimFan mentioned. To try to be as fair as possible to everyone, I think we should proceed as follows:

Eliminate The Sad Cafe, Reinstate Those Shoes, Restart the new round, give the winner of the last immunity question the option to change the song they want to make immune.

I think we have to give the winner the option to change the immunity question, especially if we want to make this a precedent for the future. If this were ever to happen again, the next time the song that twas made immune could be the one that should have been previously eliminated, so the winner would have to select another song to be immune.

I also vote for #2!

Well I vote for #2. But it does create a conundrum for me because now I want to protect two songs I really like this round. However, had I had the option at the time I would have most likely chosen Those Shoes. So if the decision is made to go with option 2 with the caveat that I get to change my choice then I would like select Those Shoes for immunity instead.

Option #2

:ack: As happy as I am to have ITC immune, WT should have the option to have Those Shoes included in her immunity options. :cry: