Printable View
I agree with Soda here. Both are excellent albums, but Desperado has a slight edge over On the Border. Personally, from start to finish, I think they are both stronger than Long Road Out of Eden, but that's JMO. Sadly ...
I cast my vote for On the Border.
For reasons which I believe are very similar to FP's, I cast my vote for Desperado.
This is a good album with songs that together make up a very listen-able, creative concept album however I consider almost every song on On the Border (as well as on the other 2 remaining albums) as displaying these qualities to a higher degree.
No question for me this time...
I cast my vote for On the Border
Eagles LP
The decision becomes more and more difficult!
I choose On the Border!
Desperado
On The Border
Hey Ticky, you need to recast your vote...."Eagles LP" is "Already Gone".
I'm sure glad that immunity can't be used in the final round. I managed to get one question answered so far (got it incorrect anyway <LOL>.)
I don't think Ticky's able to recast her vote even in the case of an error like this. I think it's against the rules.Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeA
Yep, PM is right. Sorry, but the rule is that you cannot make any changes once you have posted your vote. And Mike, as far as getting the immunity question wrong, don't worry about it. That was the round where no one got the answer, mostly because I blew the question. :doh:
I'll vote off "On the Border". I can't bear to vote off Desperado!:nope:
Sorry, guess I missed a round.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ive always been a dreamer
I might as well keep running with Desperado, though at this stage its veru close!
I'm going to try this once again. I vote for Desperado.
Did you count my last vote? I'm not on your final tally list (it was also for "Eagles").
This round my vote is for "Desperado."
Nooo Not Desperado :sad:
I cast my vote for Desperado
Hmmm Lisa, I went back and checked the votes for Round 5 and I don't see any post where you voted in that round.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa
Hey guys, don't vote off Desperado yet! Look at these pleading faces!
https://www.eaglesonlinecentral.com/...adoessmall.jpg
Don't make them ask you the hard way....
https://www.eaglesonlinecentral.com/...shootout04.jpg
SAVE DESPERADO! VOTE ON THE BORDER!
Don't shoot! I vote On The Border.
Wow - this is a very close round. Very exciting, but also, nerve-wracking! :lol:
I wanted to let everyone know that I may be a little late posting the results of this round tonight. I'm going out to dinner, but will post as soon as I get home. As always, please don't cast a vote for the next round until the results of this round are officially announced. In the meantime, if you haven't already voted in this round, you have until 8:00 p.m. tonight. As I said before, it's a tight round, so every vote counts. :thumbsup:
In a very close round, the next album to leave the island in Eagles Albums Survivor is On the Border. On the Border we have given you the best of our love up to now, but this is your good day in hell. Please leave the island immediately. The remaining albums may return to camp.
Votes
On the Border 8
Desperado 7
Vote Breakdown
On the Border EagleLady
On the Border SodaScouts
On the Border Ive always been a dreamer
On the Border timfan
On the Border Koala
On the Border MikeA
On the Border Stars
On the Border GlennLover
Desperado Freypower
Desperado LWKUA
Desperado AzEaglesFan
Desperado Glennsallnighter
Desperado TimothyBFan
Desperado Lisa
Desperado Prettymaid
Albums eliminated:
Hell Freezes Over 2/18
Eagles Live 2/20
The Long Run 2/22
One of These Nights 2/24
Eagles 2/26
On the Border 2/28
Albums remaining:
Desperado
Hotel California
Long Road Out of Eden
Okay, there are no more immunity questions in this game. These albums are now on their own.
Voting for Round 7 begins now.
I vote for Long Road Out of Eden
I vote for Desperado
I vote for Desperado
Long Road out of Eden
"Desperado"
Desperado
I vote for Desperado
I vote for Long Road out of Eden.
Wow, can't believe I lost a whole round in there...and I would've voted for Desperado, too, making it a tie...oh, brother! Oh, well, sometimes real life gets in the way of what's important, huh?
My vote in this round is also for Desperado.
Gotta vote for Long Road Out Of Eden.
Desperado. Seems like i've been voting for this album every round, except for the last round. I missed that one.
Why Desperado? :sad:
Yeah PB--You and I both!
I vote for Desperado
I'm in Pittsburgh right now about to go to the opening night of Fleetwood Mac's tour tonight - first row baby! - but I had to sign on quickly to cast a vote while my friends were busy (not sure I'll have a chance tomorrow).
I'm thrilled Desperado made it another round! Let's take it all the way to the top!
I cast my vote for Long Road Out of Eden.
You've scored 1st row seats Nancy! Congratulations girl! Way to go.......:thumbsup:. Have a brilliant night.
Now for Business as Usual.
I cast my vote this round for 'Desperado'
Desperado.
In terms of overall song quality, in my opinion Long Road Out Of Eden (and On The Border - oh well) are both far superior to the Desperado album. The sheer breadth and depth of LROOE is astounding. I suppose I was easily blown away by it, but I can't get enough of the majority of the songs, and I cannot say that about Desperado, which starts superby but trails off on Side 2.
I have to disagree there. In terms of superiority, I feel Desperado is way superior than On The Border or Long Road out of Eden. In fact, LROOE is the weakest of the two albums IMO
I cast my vote for Long Road out of Eden