Okay now - Someone else has to start answering these immunity questions other than Prettymaid because it is time for Help Me Thru The Night to go and she keeps making it immune! :wink: :wink:
Printable View
Okay now - Someone else has to start answering these immunity questions other than Prettymaid because it is time for Help Me Thru The Night to go and she keeps making it immune! :wink: :wink:
Hmmmph! I think Prettymaid is doing a FINE job of making the MOST AWESOME SONG immune!
One of us has just got to be faster than Prettymaid next time lol.
That being said I vote for Walk Away this round...
I wasn't even home when the round ended! I got here 5 minutes late and no one had answered the question yet.
Hey, if I don't keep protecting HMTTN (the little song that could), it's going to be beaten up by all the big songs! :fight:
PM is doing JUST fine little missy!! *G*
(walk away.. indeed..)
this is ...painful... but.. it gets more play then any of the others, so it need to go...
Lifes Been Good
I'll Help you PM! Im all for HMTTN (The HFO version..)
I cast my vote for Walk Away.
I'm glad we made a believer out of you, Ticky. Now everyone else go listen to the song...:grooving:Quote:
Originally Posted by ticky
"please Help me, Mama.."
http://www.tickypages.com/fun_with_s...creencap46.jpg
HOW could I say no??????
I again am casting my vote for Rocky Mountain Way.
Joe himself said this about this song.
"If I knew I'd have to play this song for the rest of my life I probably would have written something else."
I cast my vote for Rocky Mountain Way
I also cast my vote for Rocky Mountain Way.
Ooops, forgot about this the last few days, darned shoulder of mine has made it difficult to get on (but I cheered myself up with a Joe dvd that Soda gave me when she came to London :partytime:)
I'm voting for Life's Been Good
Ooops, I nearly forgot, too.
I cast my vote for Walk Away.
Well – I may be casting the tie-breaking vote here. It is very hard to do this, but it must be done.
I cast my vote for Walk Away.
In a very tight round, the next song to be voted off the island in the Joe Walsh’s Greatest Hits: Little Did He Know (aka The Definitive Collection) Survivor is Walk Away. “Walk Away” it looks like your stop so you gotta get off. Now turn your pretty head and leave the island immediately. The remaining songs may return to camp.
Votes
Walk Away – 4
Rocky Mountain Way – 3
Life’s Been Good – 2
Vote Breakdown
Walk Away– Wildthyme
Walk Away – Freypower
Walk Away – Brooke
Walk Away – Ive always been a dreamer
Rocky Mountain Way – TimothyBFan
Rocky Mountain Way – Prettymaid
Rocky Mountain Way – DonFan
Life’s Been Good – ticky
Life’s Been Good – Toonlass
Songs eliminated:
Mother Says 9/04
Midnight Man 9/06
Tend My Garden 9/08
Meadows 9/10
The Confessor 9/12
The Bomber 9/14
Ordinary Average Guy 9/16
Turn To Stone 9/18
All Night Long 9/20
A Life Of Illusion 9/22
Walk Away 9/24
Songs remaining:
Funk #49
Rocky Mountain Way
Help Me Thru The Night
Life's Been Good
Voting for Round 12 will begin after the following immunity question is answered:
What song on this ‘Definitive Collection’ album has backing vocals by members of the Eagles?
Please include both your answer and the song you wish to be immune in your reply.
I *think* its Lifes Been Good
IF Im right Immune is Help Me through the Night
No ticky - thanks for trying, but that is not correct.
I think it may have been Help Me Through The Night
If I am right then Funk #49 is immune this round
Thanks WT - That is correct. Don Henley, Glenn Frey, and Randy Meisner all provided background vocals on the 1975 studio version of this song.
Funk #49 is immune.
Round 12 begins now.
With great reluctance I cast my vote for Life's Been Good. A signature song, yes, but I like the others better.
Drat, I missed the last round, and Walk Away is gone. I've just bought You Can't Argue With A Sick Mind and there is a blistering version of it on there, not to mention that Hawaii version with Glenn. I would have voted for Funk#49 if it wasn't immune. Good grief, it's getting tough. Reluctantly, I'm also going to vote for Life's Been Good.
I vote for Help Me Through the Night.
I vote (reluctantly and with great trepidation) for *sigh* Lifes Been good
:stop: this insanity. Life's Been Good is one of the best classic rock 'n roll songs of all time. It has awesome music and some of the most clever lyrics ever! It does not deserve to go down yet. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE save it. :pray: :pray: :pray:
I agree dreamer. This is a travesty! :brickwall:
SAVE LIFE'S BEEN GOOD!
It just can't go down yet! It's a classic and so much fun!
I cast my vote for Help Me Through The Night.
Life's Been Good is a great song, but all of them are! and LBG has so much play EVERYWHERE it's over played! time for it to rest.
SAVE HELP ME THRU THE NIGHT! VOTE LIFE'S BEEN GOOD!!!
HMTTN is so amazing - moving an poignant - lovely harmonies - wonderful.
Yeah, Life's Been Good is a hoot and a signature song, but can you really say it moves you emotionally? Besides giving you a good laugh?
As you can imagine...
I cast my vote for Life's Been Good.
Okay - I gotta totally disagree here with my good friend, soda. First of all, if a song gives you a good laugh, to me that means it's moving you emotionally. However, Life's Been Good does more for me than give me a good laugh - it is the ultimate 'feel good' song. Every time I hear it, it gives me a huge emotional high. I don't think I'm the only one either - just look at the audience reaction to it at the live shows.Quote:
Originally Posted by sodascouts
I know that Life's Been Good may have been overplayed - but, so has Hotel California, Take It Easy, Desperado, and Heartache Tonight to name just a few others. However, that doesn't take away from the fact that these are all classic songs that have reached a legendary status in rock 'n roll history for good reason. As the old saying goes - "the cream rises to the top". JMHO
Well, first of all, they rarely DO HMTTN in concert, not like they do Life's Been Good or RMW, so you cant really gage this by audience reaction. Personally I get MUCH more of an emotional high from listening to HMTTN then LBG, but like you said, thats my opinion. I would really like to see something less listened to win this just because it might make people give it a second listen! HMTTN is a great song! Look at me! I started out not liking it, but it took a different version to change my mind. Now the song melts me! to ME it's the ultimate Feel Good song.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ive always been a dreamer
Hotel California and Take It Easy arent in this game so we cant vote on them. They are all great songs, but to be fair, if Hotel California and Take it easy WERE in this against say, Hollywood Waltz or Try and Love Again, I'd probably vote for one of those, because they are great songs that dont get much play! AND the cream may rise to the top, but the Buttah sinks *G*Quote:
Originally Posted by Ive always been a dreamer
I cast my vote for Help Me Thourgh the Night
I cast my vote for Help Me Thru The Night
Just because I LOVE LIFES BEEN GOOD!
I'm going to have to tip the scale a little here. It's not that I want Life's Been Good voted off bacause it's been overplayed, and I don't want to keep Help Me Thru the Night just because it's the underdog. The fact that one is a fun, sarcastic - edged song and the other a beautifully simple ballad makes this all the more interesting. But once again I have to ask myself, which do I enjoy listening to more than the other? That's really all there is to it.
I cast my vote for Life's Been Good
Brooke-couldn't have said it better myself!!!
Sorry Nancy-but you know what I am going to do here (and did I get told about it a few times last night):oops:
I vote for Help Me Thru The Night.
My vote is for Life's Been Good
Hey Toony! Fancy meeting up with your here! I've a feeling I've met up with a bunch of all you guys around the Eagles related forums. :grouphug:
I have had a hard time deciding which way to vote this time. I really like all of the songs that are left. And while I agree HMTTN is a lovely song I just can't stand seeing Life's Been Good go away yet. So I while begging for the forgiveness of my best friend ticky, I cast my vote for Help Me Through the Night...
OMG - I am so crossing my fingers that Life's Been Good will escape elimination this round. :wink: :nod: It should be no surprise ...
I cast my vote for Help Me Thru The Night.
OK everybody within the sight of this post, I am making one last effort to save Help me Thru the Night. If you feel so inclined, please vote immediately for Life's Been Good. You have until the top of the hour to cast your vote.
I thank you for your support!
In a very tight round, the next song to be voted off the island in the Joe Walsh’s Greatest Hits: Little Did He Know (aka The Definitive Collection) Survivor is Help Me Thru The Night. “Help Me Thru The Night” it was such a price to pay, but we took your dream away. You must please leave the island immediately. The remaining songs may return to camp.
Votes
Help Me Thru The Night – 7
Life’s Been Good – 6
Vote Breakdown
Help Me Thru The Night – DonFan
Help Me Thru The Night – Brooke
Help Me Thru The Night – The_Girl_Of_Summer
Help Me Thru The Night – Mrs Henley
Help Me Thru The Night – TimothyBFan
Help Me Thru The Night – Wildthyme
Help Me Thru The Night – Ive always been a dreamer
Life’s Been Good – Freypower
Life’s Been Good – glenneaglesfan
Life’s Been Good – ticky
Life’s Been Good – SodaScouts
Life’s Been Good – Prettymaid
Life’s Been Good – Toonlass
Songs eliminated:
Mother Says 9/04
Midnight Man 9/06
Tend My Garden 9/08
Meadows 9/10
The Confessor 9/12
The Bomber 9/14
Ordinary Average Guy 9/16
Turn To Stone 9/18
All Night Long 9/20
A Life Of Illusion 9/22
Walk Away 9/24
Help Me Thru The Night 9/26
Songs remaining:
Funk #49
Rocky Mountain Way
Life's Been Good
There are no more immunity questions.
Voting for Round 13 begins now.